Well it's one week later and it seems that 16,000 police did do the trick. Although I have to wonder if it has more to do with the stern telling off the PM gave the rioters, making them realize in a country that is known for being number one in the world in terms of CCTV coverage, they would be caught!
Like after any big event in society this has got people talking. There seems to be widespread condemnation for the rioters, certainly I've heard no-one trying to argue that they were in any way politically minded. A protest was organized in my suburb on the weekend, and while I was pleased to see people getting together to have their voices heard, I was a little disappointed with the messages being carried by the protesters. The majority of the posters carried two phrases 'Don't blame our kids, blame the Torries' and 'Bankers are the real looters'. Firstly I think sending the message that the rioters are not responsible for their actions is very dangerous, after all what we need is more personal responsibility not less, that's not to say that I don't think that the government has a role to play in building a society educated enough to tell right from wrong, but at the end of the day it is your decision to take part in looting or not, as with anything ignorance is no excuse! My distaste over the 'Blame the Torries banner' is that this problem has been embedded in British society much longer than the current government has been in power, the estates where gangs rule and knife crime is rife did not pop up in the last few years! I have a little bit of sympathy with the other banner, 'Bankers are the real looters'. It is true that what happened to the financial systems was driven by greed and seemed to be done in a vacuum of thought for long term consequences or responsibility to other people. Certainly drawing that parallel is interesting however in my mind the two are only loosely related and focus on bankers detracts from the real issues. If the banks had been more cautious would Britain still have under educated people living in poverty, I think so.
Thankfully these aren't the only two sentiments that are being discussed, there has been a lot of emphasis placed on what I think is at the root of the issue, that these young people did not feel part of the community. Living with my flatmate who is struggling to find work after finishing her Masters last year, I have a little bit of insight into how this could happen. She is on the benefit and has explained what it is like when sometimes they don't pay her and she has to go in and sort it out. Apparently the first question she is faced with is "How did you manage to survive without the money?", after she tells them that she tells them she had to borrow money from her friends she is asked to bring in letters from her friends confirming this. As if borrowing money from your friends wasn't degrading enough! [If this is how social services deals with an unemployed Masters student one wonders what it is like for kids growing up on estates. If the majority of interactions with the people who are supposed to help you when you are in trouble are belittling and degrading it is easy to see how you would grow a distaste for such services and even a desire to rebel against the society that is treating you will very little respect.
Still while all this discourse is great, the question still remains, what do we do to fix it? Sadly on this topic I have heard very little that is inspiring. In fact I'm appalled at one of the government's responses which is to give the councils more power to kick people out of social housing. If you think that problem is that 'society is broken', how is effectively pushing these people even further out of society going to help? Personally i don't know what the answer is either, I suspect we really need to listen to the youth themselves and the people who work with them. I hope the momentum around this issue lasts long enough to come up with some good responses. I asked my current flatmate who is politically active, "Are people still talking about this on your Facebook?", "yes", she said, " a few, what about on your Facebook?" "Well no, not really" I had to admit. The sad truth is that once things go back to normal events are quickly forgotten and people move on to the next big story the media feeds them.
No comments:
Post a Comment